1) Were you already familiar with the story of the Dionne Quintuplets? If so, how did you first learn about the sisters? If not, what surprised you about their story?
2) Did your opinion of Dr. Dafoe, the Canadian Government, or the Dionne parents change over the course of the novel? Who was in the right? Who was in the wrong?
3) Normal motherhood is absent in Quintland. Real or substitute mothers in the book can’t or don’t ‘mother’ according to conventional norms and would-be mothers are eager to get their hands on the magical “quintstones.” Emma herself insists she has no intention of becoming a mother. What are the essential components of motherhood and how were these present or absent in the lives of the quintuplets?
4) Emma insists she’d be happy to stay at the Dafoe Nursery for as long as she possibly can, but what are her motives for staying? Are they purely altruistic, or are they selfish?
5) Emma tries, with pencils and paintbrushes, to capture the true individuality of each Dionne girl in her art. But Emma’s art also helps to perpetuate a fairytale, make-believe world. Discuss how Emma’s progress as an artist serves as a metaphor for the deepening tensions at the heart of Quintland.
6) The Quintland Sisters, we learn at the outset of the book, consists of archival ‘fonds’—as if these official documents, in some way, represent a formal record of events. How do these documents both support and undermine the central ‘facts’ of the Dionne story? What do we gain from seeing this world from Emma’s vantage point? What do we lose?
7) Emma prides herself on noticing quirky details, yet her eyes are so focused on her young charges that she fails to fully see what’s going on around her. At the same time, the people in power in Quintland work hard to make sure the public sees only the official version of events and nothing more. What echoes does Emma’s predicament share with modern day celebrity and those who work in the margins of fame?
8) Imagine the Dionne sisters being born today, under similar circumstances, but in the era of social media and a 24-hour news cycle? Would they have fared better or worse?